---
title: How to check that a Mac converter doesn't upload your files
source: https://arazioformac.com/notes/check-a-mac-converter-does-not-upload
---

# How to check that a Mac converter doesn't upload your files

An app that says "your files never leave your Mac" is making a claim you can
test. You do not have to take the developer's word for it, mine included.

**The short answer:** open **Activity Monitor**, go to the **Network** tab, convert
a large file, and watch the **Sent Bytes** column for that app. If the number
climbs by roughly the size of your file, the file is being uploaded. For a
stricter test, turn Wi-Fi off and convert again. If it still works, it cannot
have been using a server.

Four checks follow, from quickest to most thorough. None of them needs any
technical background for the first two.

## Check 1: turn the internet off

The simplest test, and the hardest to argue with.

1. Turn Wi-Fi off (and unplug Ethernet if you use it).
2. Convert a file.

If the conversion works, the app did not need a server for it. If it fails, or
asks you to connect, the file was going somewhere.

**The catch:** some apps need the internet for something unrelated to the file,
such as checking a licence, so a failure is a prompt to look closer and not
proof on its own. A success, though, is strong evidence.

## Check 2: Activity Monitor

Built into every Mac, and it shows traffic per app.

1. Open **Activity Monitor** (Applications → Utilities).
2. Click the **Network** tab.
3. Find the app, then note its **Sent Bytes**.
4. Convert a file of known size, a few hundred megabytes if you have one.
5. Look at **Sent Bytes** again.

An upload shows up as sent data close to the file's size. A few kilobytes is
normal and means the app just checked something small, such as for updates.

**The catch:** Activity Monitor shows how much was sent, not where. And a
background process can send data at the same moment, so use a big file and
close other apps first.

## Check 3: see every connection

To see where an app connects, use a network monitor or firewall.

- **LuLu** is a free, open-source firewall from Objective-See. It alerts you
  when an app tries to connect and lets you allow or block it.
- **Little Snitch** is a long-established commercial firewall that shows every
  connection, with the destination, as it happens.

Run the converter with one of them active, convert a file, and see what it
tries to reach. Better still, **block** the app and convert again. If it works
blocked, nothing it needed was on the network.

Terminal can do a quick version too:

```
lsof -i -n -P | grep -i appname
```

lists the network connections an app has open right now. Replace `appname`
with part of the app's name. For live traffic per process, run `nettop`.

**The catch:** a firewall tells you about connections. It cannot tell you what
was sent over one, only to whom and how much.

## Check 4: read what the developer actually claims

Marketing says "private". A specific claim can be tested. Compare:

- "We take privacy seriously." Nothing to test.
- "Files are deleted after 24 hours." This means they were uploaded.
- "The conversion engines contain no networking code." This is a claim about
  how the app is built, and you can check it from the outside with the three
  tests above.

**For a sandboxed app,** one more check exists: its entitlements. Run
`codesign -d --entitlements - /Applications/AppName.app` and look for
`com.apple.security.network.client`. If it is absent, a sandboxed app cannot
open outgoing connections at all. This only applies to sandboxed apps, so it
does not tell you anything about one that is not.

## What a clean result looks like, and what it does not prove

A converter that does not upload will usually show:

- the conversion working with the internet off,
- almost no sent data in Activity Monitor during the conversion,
- connections only for things like updates or licensing, if any.

That does not mean the app makes no connections at all. Plenty of honest apps
check for updates or confirm a licence, and that is expected.

## What Arazio does, so you can test it

I build Arazio, so here is exactly what to expect.

The conversion engines contain **no networking code**, and a test fails the
build if a networking symbol turns up in them. Two things do use the network,
and neither carries a file:

- **Licence activation:** one request when you activate, carrying the licence
  key.
- **Update checks:** the app asks whether a newer version exists, sending the
  version you run and nothing else. You can switch this off in Settings, after
  which Arazio makes no network requests at all.

There is no analytics, no telemetry and no account. To verify: convert with
Wi-Fi off, watch Sent Bytes in Activity Monitor, or block the app in LuLu and
convert again. The details are on the
[privacy and permissions page](/docs/privacy).

## Common questions

**How can I tell if a Mac converter uploads my files?** Turn off Wi-Fi and
convert, or watch the app's Sent Bytes in Activity Monitor while converting a
large file.

**Does an offline converter ever use the internet?** Sometimes, for updates or
to check a licence. That is different from uploading a file, and a firewall such
as LuLu or Little Snitch shows you which is which.

**Are online converters unsafe?** They have to receive your file to convert it,
so you are trusting the company to delete it. For sensitive files, converting on
your own Mac removes the question.

See also: [Arazio's privacy and permissions](/docs/privacy), and the
comparisons for [CloudConvert](/notes/cloudconvert-alternative-for-mac) and
[Permute](/notes/permute-alternative-for-mac).
